The number of closings in all three measures has increased, year over year, each month for the past four months.
This recent growth trend has also begun to show up in the 12-month moving averages used to track trends in home sales. The highly-cyclical nature of home sales trends makes it difficult to track multi-year trends in home sales. The addition of the homebuyer tax credits from 2008 to 2010 further complicated the picture. So, I have smoothed out the sales totals using a 12-month moving average for each month.
In the first graph, we see the moving average in home sales compared to year-over-year changes in the average for the metro Denver area. The trend in home sales closing has been downward since mid-2005 and accelerated in early 2009. From March 2008 until September 2011, every month showed a negative year-over-year change in home sales. In October, the year-over-year change was positive for the first time in 45 months, with an increase of 0.3 percent. As indicated by the moving averages themselves, overall home sales numbers have been flat since early 2009.
The second graph shows the same measurements for Colorado statewide. The year-over-year change in the statewide average for home sales turned positive in October for the first time in 12 months. Statewide, transactions moved into positive territory during some month during which the homebuyer tax credits were offered in 2010. The average increased 0.8 percent in October, year over year.
The third graph shows the same measures for the Pikes Peak region. The homebuyer tax credit produced much larger changes in the regional trends in the Pikes Peak region than in metro Denver or statewide. The year over year change in October was negative, making it the twelfth month in a row that produced a negative year over year change in the moving average for home sales. Nevertheless, the magnitude of the negative change has decreased each month for the past five months. Excluding the run-up in home sales produced by the tax credit in 2009 and 2010, the average in home sales has been largely flat since mid-2009 in the Pikes Peak region.
The analysis of moving averages in home sales activity indicates that the markets continue to stabilize in metro Denver, the Pikes Peak region, and statewide. Overall activity has been flat since 2009, but recent upward trends suggest that sales activity will continue to build at least in the near term. Sales totals, however, are likely to continue to be well below peak levels for at least the next year.
